December 29, 1997
Last week I shared the US Department of Energy Industrial Assessment Centers’ “Top Ten” list of low cost actions that would produce the greatest immediate impact as cost cutting measures by industry. (See NBL 6.24, in case you missed it.)
A number of readers were grateful, so I thought I’d rummage my list of lists for lists that are both useful individually and perhaps offer some additional insight in juxtaposition. (As you will see, these tend to be design criteria lists, rather than more implementation oriented lists like the Business Charter for Sustainable Development <http://www.iccwbo.org>; and the CERES Principles <http://www.ceres.org>;.)
So here they are, undigested food for thought, cryptic enough for plenty of new year’s musing. A do it yourself New Bottom Line. Please chew thoroughly before swallowing.
One certainty faced by business (not to mention government, and just folks) is uncertainty. Another is change. So these criteria for resilience — the ability of a system to response to change and maintain its integrity — offered by noted ecologist C. S. Hollings seem a good place to start:
Hardin Tibbs, in his seminal paper “Industrial Ecology – An Agenda for Environmental Management,” identified key ecosystem characteristics that could guide potential industrial ecosystems. Tibbs’ “Core Principles for Industrial Ecosystems” include:
Tibbs went on to suggest a program of transition for industrial society that focused on:
Living Machine inventor Dr John Todd and industrial engineer Dr Douglas Holmes took their own look at industrial ecosystem design criteria in 1995:
The Natural Step program’s four “system conditions” (which we’ve written about often in NBL) suggest that for there to be a sustainable society+ecosphere:
(I’m inclined to add a fifth: Any ecologically sustainable solutions had better be economically viable, or they’re not likely to be widely adopted.)
In a recent design seminar with University of California engineering students, I identified yet another collection of “Industrial Ecology Design Principles” that clustered under three main themes:
William McDonough, designer and Dean of Architecture at the University of Virginia reduces it all to a simple and elegant formulation:
(In recent talks McDonough has added one more extremely powerful criterion, ascribed to Curitiba mayor Jaime Lerner: Love all the children.)
Finally, here are a simple few that seem to keep showing up on my personal radar:
And what continues to resonate as the central business proposition for the 21st century:
More value. Less stuff.
Your challenge: put these lists to work.